Skip to content
  • Join
  • Login
wasmormon.org

wasmormon.org

Stories of mormon faith transitions. Share your truth – own your story!

  • Profiles
  • Create Profile
  • Questions
  • Blog
  • About

Hi, I’m Tad

I was a mormon.

Atlanta, Georgia
tadell12 profile image for wasmormon.org

    About me

    I was raised in a 100% Mormon family in Atlanta, Georgia. Growing up, I was part of youth groups, scouts, and all other Mormon-adjacent things in the early 2000s. I always figured that if the Church wasn't true, then God must not exist. I was swept up in the New Atheism movement in my teens, and quickly lost faith in God. However, with the pressures of family at that time to serve an LDS Mission, I pretty much elected to gaslight myself into believing again. This led to a lot of cognitive dissonance. To my credit, I tried very hard, especially in the MTC and beyond, to obtain a testimony for myself. I committed to hours of intense, dedicated prayer in order to receive a witness of the Book of Mormon, or a "burning in the bosom", but it never came. I persevered; finished my mission honorably, went to BYU and got married, all while basically over-committing myself to the faith. I went to the temple frequently, had callings in my ward, etc. But all the while, something was festering that I could not shake.

    On my shelf

    • book of mormon origin and translation
    • Book of Mormon anachronisms
    • coffee
    • DNA and the Book of Mormon
    • historicity of book of mormon
    • Joseph Smith's polygamy
    • feelings over facts
    • Heavenly Mother
    • Letter for My Wife
    • Mark Hofmann forgeries
    • polygamy
    • church history
    • corporation of the church
    • Brigham Young's polygamy

    On the Mormon Spectrum

    • Atheist
    • Exmormon
    • Existential Crisis
    • Intellectual
    • Faith Crisis
    • Doubting
    • Born in the Covenant

    # Why I left More stories of 'Why I left' the Mormon church

    Around 2022 or so, I was still an active, tithe-paying, normal church member, and my wife and I had just had our newborn daughter. I heard on the news about a whistleblower alleging that the LDS church had been lying/defrauding the government through funneling donations and other moneys into shell corporations so as to basically hide taxable income from the IRS/SEC. This was quite a shock to me, and it ended up setting off a domino effect. I finally allowed myself for the first time ever, after a lifetime of avoiding "Anti-Mormon" content, to listen to the Last Podcast on the Left episodes on Mormonism. That led me further to Mormon Stories, which became my undoing. It was clear to me things that had always bothered me, such as Polygamy, were completely indefensible. I had been told growing up that Joseph Smith had only one wife, and that Brigham Young started polygamy. Once I realized how depraved and disgusting Joseph Smith was in his treatment of women, especially his own wife, the "elect lady", it really came crashing down. I never felt the Spirit confirming to me the veracity of the Book of Mormon, but reading D&C 132 critically for the first time gave me such a dark impression. This led to the further deconstruction of church history, the Book of Mormon, church practices, and really everything after. Since, in my mind, the LDS Church had such a strong claim on the truth, if it was wrong then surely Christianity and God must come crashing down with it. And for me, for a time, they did. For about 2-3 years I was enveloped in a dreadful existential crisis. I flew through the works of Nietzsche, Camus, Schopenhauer, and others in my attempt to find peace in the wake of a total religious deconstruction. After a time, I did come to peace with the idea that there was no God, and finally was able to settle my restless mind and focus on the time I had with my family. It was all ok. We continued to attend the LDS ward where we lived, but I never told my wife the extent of my unbelief and simply went on with my life, apathetic towards religion.

    But it was not the end. Around 2025, I felt something pull me towards looking into early Christianity. Now, the purpose of this is not to advocate for any specific religious persuasion; merely to give some examples of how religion can be without all the lies and propaganda about history and doctrine that the LDS church put on me in my upbringing. As I looked into early Christian history, it was apparent to me that an LDS "Great Apostasy" never happened. I became drawn towards Catholicism, and could not shake the beauty of that faith. I don't quite remember how, but my wife and I began to discuss religion more in depth, and she confided to me that she hated wearing the LDS Garments, and as soon as I showed her the Masonic origins of them, and the lack of any early Christian or pre-Christian mention of Mormon doctrines such as temple ceremonies and polygamy, her shelf quickly broke. We now attend a Catholic Church, and while the Catholic Church has certainly had its own issues, I was surprised that they did not let us join until we took in depth courses on church doctrine and history, and they did not shy away from the tough questions. They had nothing to hide. I was also shocked to receive a financial statement of how my parish was spending the funds I donated. I could not believe the financial transparency and accountability! My point here is mainly that it is a beautiful thing to pursue the faith (or lack thereof) that you really identify with, without anyone brainwashing or gaslighting you into ignoring historical fact or overlooking certain negative things. I finally felt free to decide for myself what I felt I was being led to, without a care for what anyone else around me thought, and without any coercive action impressing upon me. There can be a beautiful life after deconstruction, and as difficult as it can be mentally, as well as socially, it is 100% worth it to be authentic to what you believe.

    Questions about Mormons My Answers to Questions about Mormonism

    #Link to this answer of 'Have you had any profound spiritual moments in your life?' by tadell12 Have you had any profound spiritual moments in your life? See more answers about 'Have you had any profound spiritual moments in your life?'

    Partaking of the Eucharist each Sunday Mass is the spiritual high point of my life. It is like what the LDS Temple ceremonies are supposed to be; truly beautiful & Christ-centered worship, minus the creepy cultishness and Masonic influences. There is nothing I have felt more powerfully than being in communion with the Jesus Christ in the Eucharist.

    #Link to this answer of 'Do you believe the Book of Mormon is true?' by tadell12 Do you believe the Book of Mormon is true? See more answers about 'Do you believe the Book of Mormon is true?'

    No. The Book of Mormon clearly exhibits 19th century theology & myths of the time and place in which it was written. It is full of literary and technological / cultural anachronisms, and could have only been written by someone living in the time and place Joseph Smith was in.

    #Link to this answer of 'What do you feel or know about polygamy?' by tadell12 What do you feel or know about polygamy? See more answers about 'What do you feel or know about polygamy?'

    Polygamy is evil. God never once commanded it in the Old Testament (I was told this was true growing up, which was a lie) and Jesus set out the code for marriage in the Gospels, that being between 1 man and 1 woman, indissoluble. Joseph Smith cannot override Jesus Christ in my book, and no LDS apologist has ever been able to defend polygamy because it is frankly disgusting and an affront to human nature and to Christianity itself and God's design for marriage.

    More Atheist Stories

    tadell12 profile image for wasmormon.orgtadell12I was a mormon.Misora profile image for wasmormon.orgMisoraI was once a Mormon. Thank the universe I am not anymore.Noal Davis profile image for wasmormon.orgNoal DavisBorn & raised in Norther Utah, I quickly learned that my personal value was only connected to my obedience to the Mormon faith. I was, but am no longer, a MormonSpencer Warner profile image for wasmormon.orgSpencer WarnerI enjoy skiing, technology, and skepticism. I was a mormon.Frey Higley profile image for wasmormon.orgFrey HigleyI enjoy the culinary arts, theatre, and sewing. I was a mormon.blackheart profile image for wasmormon.orgblackheartI was a mormon.
    Contribute your own story
    Browse Stories
    Random Story
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • Reddit
    • Bluesky
    • Mastodon
    • Twitter
    • RSS Feed

    Register or Log In

    Lost your password? Register

    Forgotten Password

    Cancel

    Register For This Site

    A password will be e-mailed to you.

    Ready to start your profile now? (everything below is optional)

    In order to complete your profile and add it to the site you’ll need to click the link you receive in your email. Then you can add a photo and more to your story.

    This greeting will display at the top of your profile. It's how you greet readers.

    This is for a very short tagline. It will display just below the greeting.

    Tell us a bit about yourself, be sure to include a Mormon context. This sets up the story you share so readers know where you're coming from.

    Describe your shelf items, your struggles with the church, what you did about it all. Be sure to include and conclusions you made about the church.

    We’re honored you’ve chosen to share your story with us!


    Cancel

    Subscribe

    Sign up to receive the monthly newsletter!
    wasmormon.org

    Though this site discusses mormonism, topics related to mormons, the mormon church and people who refer to themselves as unorthodox mormons, ex-mormons, post-mormons or any other form of wasmormon, it is not officially affiliated with or managed by The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints or even the Corporation of the Presiding Bishop. They don't want to be called mormon anymore anyways. All of the content, stories or opinions expressed, implied or included in this site are solely credited to those sharing their own personal stories and not those of Intellectual Reserve, Inc. or The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.

    Privacy Policy
    • Stories
    • Questions
    • Blog
    • Church Leadership
    • Images
    • About
    • Resources
    • Contact
    • How To Help
    • Community Guidelines